Comparison

Cast iron skillet vs. Dutch oven: which one goes camping?

Both are heavy black cast iron, and both show up on every camp cooking list. They do very different jobs. Here’s which one your family will actually use, and when it is worth packing both.

Short answer

Most families should buy a 10-inch cast iron skillet first. It works on the propane camp stove you already own, cooks eggs, pancakes, bacon, burgers, quesadillas, and grilled cheese in minutes, weighs about five pounds, and costs around $20. A camp Dutch oven is the second piece. Its three legs and rimmed lid let you put charcoal underneath and on top, which turns it into an outdoor oven for chili, stew, a turkey breast, cobbler, and bread. That makes it the better tool for cold-weather trips and holiday meals, when a hot one-pot dinner matters more than speed. The tradeoffs are weight, at roughly 12 to 15 pounds, a learning curve with coals, and cook times of an hour or more. If you camp in fall and winter or cook for a big group, plan on owning both.

 SkilletLodge 10.25" Cast Iron SkilletDutch ovenLodge 10-inch Camp Dutch Oven (with lid lip)
Best atBreakfast, searing, frying, grilled cheeseStews, chili, roasts, cobbler, bread
Heat sourceCamp stove or grate over the fireCharcoal on the lid and underneath
Cook time5 to 20 minutes45 minutes to 2 hours
WeightAbout 5 lbAbout 12 to 15 lb
FeedsA family of four in two batchesA family of four to six in one pot
Learning curveEasyA few practice meals
Price~$20~$70

Prices approximate and subject to change on Amazon. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

A pan versus an oven

A skillet is a frying pan. Heat comes from below, the sides are low, and food cooks fast and in the open where you can see it and flip it. That is exactly what a camp breakfast or a quick lunch needs, and it is why the skillet gets used at nearly every meal.

A camp Dutch oven is a heavy pot with a lid that becomes an oven. Coals underneath heat the bottom, coals on the flat lid heat the top, and the thick iron holds an even temperature for an hour or more. It bakes, braises, and simmers, and it keeps food hot long after the coals die down. The tradeoff is time and attention: you plan the meal around it instead of tossing something in the pan.

Which wins for…

Breakfast and quick weeknight-style meals

The skillet, easily. Pancakes, eggs, bacon, and breakfast potatoes all come off a hot skillet on the stove in the time it takes to light a chimney of charcoal. Our easy family camping meals are built mostly around a skillet and one pot.

Cold nights and hot one-pot dinners

The Dutch oven. Chili, beef stew, or chicken and dumplings hold their heat in thick iron long enough for everyone to get seconds before it cools, which matters on a 35-degree evening. Our cold-weather camping meals guide covers which recipes hold up best when the temperature drops.

A holiday meal at camp

The Dutch oven for the main, the skillet for the sides. A 3 to 4 pound turkey breast fits a 10-inch camp oven, while reheated stuffing and green beans warm up in the skillet on the stove. Our Thanksgiving camping with kids guide has the full coal math and timing.

Desserts kids remember

The Dutch oven. A dump cake, which is canned fruit, a box of cake mix, and pats of butter, bakes under coals in about 45 minutes and is the dessert kids talk about on the drive home. The skillet makes a decent giant cookie over a low fire, but it is easier to scorch.

Burn bans and stove-only campgrounds

The skillet. When charcoal and campfires are banned, a propane stove is usually still allowed, and the skillet works on it as well as it does at home. A Dutch oven can simmer on a stove too, but it loses its main trick, baking with heat from above.

Cast iron around kids

Cast iron stays dangerously hot for a long time after you take it off the heat, and a handle looks exactly the same hot or cold. Keep a heavy leather glove or a thick pot holder with the pan, set hot iron down only on the stove or on a fire-safe spot away from where kids walk, and make a habit of saying “hot pan” out loud every time you move it.

Kids can still help. Older kids can crack eggs into the skillet with an adult at the stove, or layer a dump cake into a cold Dutch oven before the coals go on. Lifting a coal-covered lid is an adult job, and it needs a lid lifter, not a stick. An instant-read thermometer like the TempPro TempSwift Instant Read Meat Thermometer (~$16) takes the guesswork out of whether the meat inside is done.

Frequently asked

Should I buy a cast iron skillet or a Dutch oven first for camping?

Buy the skillet first. A 10-inch skillet cooks breakfast, burgers, quesadillas, grilled cheese, and fried potatoes on the camp stove you already own, it weighs about five pounds, and it costs around $20. A camp Dutch oven is the second piece, for families who want stews, chili, cobbler, and roasts and are willing to manage charcoal.

Can I use a regular kitchen Dutch oven for camping?

On a camp stove or a grate over the fire, yes, as long as it is bare cast iron and not enameled, since enamel can crack over uneven flame. For baking with coals, no. A camp Dutch oven has three legs that hold it above the briquettes and a flat, rimmed lid that holds coals on top. A flat-bottomed kitchen pot sits right on the coals and burns the bottom of the food.

How many charcoal briquettes does a 10-inch Dutch oven need?

For about 350 degrees, use roughly 20 briquettes: about 14 on the lid and 6 underneath. Add a few more on a cold or windy day, and turn the lid a quarter turn and the pot a quarter turn the other way every 15 minutes so no spot burns. Check meat with an instant-read thermometer rather than trusting the clock.

How do you clean cast iron at a campsite?

Scrape it while it is still warm, wipe it with a little hot water and a scrubber, and skip long soaks. Dry it completely over the stove or the coals for a minute, then rub in a thin film of cooking oil before it goes back in the bin. A drop of mild soap is fine on modern pre-seasoned cast iron. Rust comes from putting it away wet, not from the soap.

See the picks

Keep going

Planning the menu?

A full weekend of family meals, with a shopping list and what to prep at home.

Read the family camping meal plan